Crowd Watch
Loading...

How to Actually Get Your First Users from Reddit (Without Getting Eaten Alive)

By Jonathan Hayka
SaaS
Marketing
Reddit
Growth

Alright, so you built something. You poured your soul into this thing, coded late nights, sketched designs on napkins, whatever your process was. It exists! But now... silence. You launch, and maybe your mom signs up. How do you bridge that gap between having a product and having users – those real people who kick the tires, tell you what's broken, and maybe even start telling their friends?

Lots of ways to tackle this, but let's talk about Reddit. It's this massive collection of super-focused communities, basically a goldmine if you know how to approach it. But it's not just another place to spam your link. Reddit has its own vibe, its own rules (written and unwritten), and users who can smell a sales pitch a mile away. Do it right, find genuine fans. Do it wrong, get downvoted into nothingness and maybe even banned.

Here’s a more grounded approach to finding your first few users on Reddit:

  1. 1. Forget the Hard Sell. Seriously. Be Human First.

    This is the absolute bedrock. If you walk into a subreddit waving your product around like a banner, you'll get shut down fast. Redditors hate blatant marketing. Your first mission isn't getting sign-ups; it's becoming a real, contributing member of the places where your potential users already are. Think conversation, not conversion (at least initially).

  2. 2. Find Your People: Where Do They Actually Hang Out?

    Okay, where are these potential users on Reddit?

    • Start Broad, Then Zoom In: What problem does your thing solve? What industry is it for? What are the hobbies or jobs of the people who'd use it? Jot down keywords.
    • Dig Deeper than the Obvious: Sure, r/technology is huge, but probably too general. If you made something for indie authors, look at r/writing, r/worldbuilding, r/selfpublish. Productivity tool? Try r/productivity, r/GetDisciplined, or maybe subreddits for specific careers where efficiency matters (like r/sysadmin or r/projectmanagement).
    • Look for "Pain Point" Subs: Are there communities literally dedicated to complaining about the exact problem you solve? Bingo. These can be amazing listening posts.
    • Check the Sidebars: Most subreddits link to related communities. Explore those connections.
  3. 3. Hang Out, Listen, and Actually Contribute (This Isn't Optional)

    Before you breathe a word about your project:

    • Read the Dang Rules: Every subreddit has 'em, usually in the sidebar. Read them. Twice. Breaking rules (especially around self-promo) is the quickest ticket to getting booted.
    • Get the Vibe: How do people talk? What gets upvoted? What are the running jokes? What do people constantly complain about or ask for help with? Soak it in.
    • Be Genuinely Useful: This is non-negotiable. Answer questions you can answer. Share interesting stuff (that isn't yours!). Offer advice related to the sub's topic – ideally, stuff in the same universe as your product's solution, but don't mention your product yet. Upvote good comments and posts. Basically, be the kind of user you'd want to see. This builds trust and your Reddit "karma" (reputation score).
  4. 4. The "Gentle Ask": Trading Your Idea for Honest Feedback

    Okay, you've been around, you're not a total stranger, you've actually helped people (this might take days, or more likely, weeks). Now you can carefully test the waters. The best angle? Ask for feedback.

    • Be Humble: Try something like:

      "Hey folks in [Subreddit Name], I've been chipping away at a [tool/service] aimed at helping with [problem X - make sure it's relevant here!]. It's super early, rough around the edges, but I'd be incredibly grateful for some honest thoughts from people who actually deal with this stuff. Anyone willing to take a quick look and tell me what they really think?"

    • Pick Your Spot: Maybe start in smaller, focused subs where you've built some goodwill, or try dedicated feedback zones like r/alphaandbetausers, r/SideProject, or r/TestMyApp.
    • Be Upfront: "Yeah, I'm the one building this." "It's definitely still in beta." Honesty works.
    • Sweeten the Pot (Optional): Early access, a future discount, or just heaps of genuine appreciation can go a long way.
    • Reply to Everything: Seriously, engage with every comment. Thank people (even the harsh ones!). Answer questions. Don't get defensive – feedback, even blunt feedback, is gold right now. Listen more than you talk.
  5. 5. The "Show Off" Post (If and When It Makes Sense)

    Some communities are okay with more direct announcements, if you've earned it and follow their specific rules (like "Showoff Saturdays" in some tech subs, or specific flair requirements). This usually comes after you've already gotten some feedback and improved things.

    • Lead with the Problem: Start with the pain you're easing, then introduce your solution.
    • Keep it Tight: What is it? Who's it for? Why'd you build it? Get to the point.
    • Clear Link/Action: Tell people where to go.
    • Redditor Perk (Good Idea): A small discount or bonus for the community shows you appreciate them.
    • Stick Around: Don't just post and vanish. Hang out in the comments for hours afterward. Answer questions, take notes. This is make-or-break for launch posts.

Seriously, Don't Do This Stuff on Reddit:

  • Drive-By Linking: Joining, dropping your link, and bouncing? Everyone sees it, everyone hates it.
  • Ignoring the Rules: Fastest way to get banned. Period.
  • Being Shady: Using fake accounts to upvote yourself or leave fake positive comments? Against site rules, often obvious, and kills your credibility if caught.
  • Arguing About Feedback: Someone rips into your idea? "Thanks for the honest feedback, appreciate you taking the time." Don't fight.
  • Making it All About You: Keep participating normally in the communities, not just when you have something to promote.

Quick Word: Don't Put All Your Eggs in the Reddit Basket

Reddit's great for specific niches, but remember other places exist:

  • LinkedIn: Good for B2B stuff. Talk about your journey, connect with others in your field.
  • Twitter / X: Good for quick updates, "building in public," finding other founders and early adopters via hashtags.
  • Facebook Groups: Similar to Reddit – find relevant groups, join the conversation before pitching.
  • Instagram/TikTok: If your product is visual, show it off here with cool visuals or behind-the-scenes stuff.

Wrapping Up

Getting those first users isn't instant. It takes legwork. Reddit can be a fantastic source if you treat it like a collection of actual communities, not just a bulletin board. Show up, be helpful, listen hard, and ask humbly. Put in the time, and you might just find your first dedicated fans hiding in a subreddit.